We Tested 50 Pairs of Slippers — These Cozy, Supportive Picks Were Our Favorites

These Solei Sea Aspen clogs effortlessly blend plushness with support. The luxurious faux-fur upper is soft and warm, while the footbed is cushioned and features built-in arch support. The sole is sturdy and suitable for indoor and outdoor use. The lightweight, durable midsole is made of 30 percent natural cork with 70 percent recycled thermoplastic rubber. The round resin buckle detail gives them an elevated look. The entire construction is 100-percent vegan.

We thought these slippers were really fabulous. “They're super-comfortable. I love the arch support!” said Everyday Health editor Ashley Ziegler. They come in women’s whole sizes and four color options.

If you’re looking for luxurious warmth for just under $60, look no further than these Mykos Lia scuffs. But a lower price doesn’t mean sacrificing quality. They have a cushy, supportive “OrthoLite” foam insole, a soft faux-fur lining, a suede upper with cozy plush sheepskin scuff, and a “rubberlon” sole that can take you indoors or out. These were one of our tester’s favorites she’s tried.

“These are one of the most comfortable pairs of slippers I’ve tried,” said Everyday Health editorial director Simone Scully after she tested these. “They're warm on your feet (but not so warm that your feet sweat) and they're very comfy.” The animal-based materials mean these aren’t suitable for vegans. Also, the backless design means your ankles aren’t covered. We highly recommend them to anyone who needs a comfy, warm pair of winter slippers that won’t break the bank.

Warmer months need support, too. We were very pleasantly surprised by these Totes slides. They are supportive, waterproof, antimicrobial, and very high quality. Made of patented, super-cushy Everywear material, they are available in five colors in women’s whole sizes.

“These slides are extremely comfortable. The insole is covered with tiny nubs, which feel great when you walk, while also providing traction within the shoe itself,” said Everyday Health editor Katie Tuttle, who tried these slippers out. “They have a surprising amount of arch support. I have plantar fasciitis and found myself reaching for these frequently when walking around the house. These were much more well-made than I'd anticipated; I didn't expect to like these as much as I did.” 

“These are very comfortable. The inside is very soft, and these are very nice to wear,” said Everyday Health editor Nicole Bonaccorso, who tested these recently. A note, though: It’s recommended to wear these barefoot. The wool is meant to mold to the shape of your feet during the first month or so of use. During this time, the slippers naturally shed, but this will eventually stop. We love that these are available in a huge range of sizes, from kids’ 2.5 to men’s 17.

We loved these Alo Recovery slippers, which feature lightweight cushioning and a supportive, high-rebound insole. The suede outer and cozy faux fur liner keep your feet warm, while the slip-resistant rubber sole offers good traction.

“These slippers are extremely comfortable. They would work well for people who are very active and need a slipper that can either be active with them or give the support and comfort needed to feel strong and solid after a good workout,” said Everyday Health writer Julia Pelly, MPH. “It’s the kind of support that leaves you refreshed and reenergized instead of achy and sore. 

Orthofeet is synonymous with high-quality, stylish orthopedic shoes. If you have arthritis, bunions, diabetes, flat feet, heel pain or spurs, hammertoes, plantar fasciitis, overpronation, or even back, hip, or knee pain, these Lorin slippers are for you. They feature a slip-resistant sole, water-repellent suede, a wide toe box, arch support, a cushioned heel, and a bootie design that offers full ankle support. When Everyday Health writer Raki Swanson tested them, she said they were a perfect option for people who can’t wear traditional slippers because they aren't supportive enough.

“They are very comfortable and have a lot of cushion when you walk. You can wear these slippers for hours and hours,” she said. “Your feet do not get sweaty, while they remain just the right amount of warm.” They have a hands-free slip-on and are available in three widths and eight colors. If you’re looking for a similar style in men’s sizes, check out the Orthofeet Vito. 

Want another natural-material option? Try these Vivobarefoot wool slippers with thin leather outsoles. They’re just the thing for people who hate wearing shoes and prefer to feel their feet on the ground. At just under 5 ounces (oz), they’re super-lightweight and easy to pack in a carry-on bag or hiking backpack. During testing, Swanson found that the wool kept her feet at just the right temperature, preventing overheating or sweating.

“You can feel the ground beneath you. The leather, in addition to the thickness of the slipper itself, is close to the ground,” she said. “These would be perfect for anyone whose feet sweat in warm slippers or [want] a more-flexible type of slipper.” The wool molds to your feet. We love that each pair is made by Mongolian craftswomen. 

Xero Shoes Pagosa Cozy Slippers are another great lightweight, flexible option. At only 4.8 oz each, they’re just the thing for taking on vacation, on a camping trip, or tossing in your tote bag to wear under your desk at work. These are more substantial than the Vivobarefoot slippers, as they feature a synthetic wool upper, faux shearling lining, and a rubber outsole suitable for outdoor use. They have a roomy toe box, slip-on design with a collapsible heel, and are 100-percent vegan. They’re also tester-approved.

“These are so comfortable. They really do feel like being barefoot but better,” said Everyday Health editor Alexandra Klausner. “They are warm without making my feet too hot and are comfy with or without socks. I was able to wear them as an outdoor shoe with no issues.” We love that they are unisex, available in a wide range of sizes, and that the soles are backed by a 5,000-mile warranty. Be warned: They lack any midsole or cushioning beyond the fur lining and the rubber sole, so if you need more foot support, they might not be the right pair for you.

We love these Dearfoams Kids’ Critter Slippers. They’re machine-washable and feature super-cushy memory foam insoles, slip-resistant outsoles, and plush faux-fur lining. The easy slip-on design includes heel coverage to help them stay on. There are nearly two dozen adorable critter designs to choose from, like unicorn, cat, dog, shark, dinosaur, cow, bear, fox, raccoon, and seasonal picks like snowmen.

“My son loved wearing these and thought they were very comfortable,” said Scully. “He said they were the most comfortable of the three he tried.” On the downside, our tester’s dog thought these looked like a dog toy, because they're so puffy and stuffed animal-like. We suggest keeping an eye on them if you have dogs that love to chew. 

As someone with wide feet, I tend to struggle with slippers pinching, being hard to get on, or being so tight my pinky toes start to get tingly. Not so with these Cozy Earth Puffy Sheep Slippers. Since they don’t have a structured upper, my feet comfortably slide in and are never needlessly squished or shaped — just gently cradled and held. They are very plush and cozy, and feel luxurious and comfortable for walking, standing, and sitting.

They are also super-warm. I have Raynaud's syndrome, which means my fingers and toes are constantly cold, and if I don’t work to keep them warm, they quickly go numb. These slippers have become my go-to daily choice for keeping my feet warm. They also stay on my feet despite being backless slip-ons. My only complaints are that I need to wear socks to keep my ankles warm, and the sole could do with a bit more cushioning.

When I was looking for gift ideas last holiday season, someone recommended UnHide. I’m so glad I listened. The UnHide throw blanket I bought for my son is the softest thing I’ve ever felt. I continue to buy products from the company to send as gifts to friends and family. These slippers are made of that same faux fur fabric, and they’re like a little fur sleeping bag for each foot. Ziegler, who got to try these out, really enjoyed wearing them and found them surprisingly cushioned and supportive.

“The footbed is really comfortable, and the faux fur is really soft,” she said. “The sole is super-cushy, so I think they're a good option for someone with high arches or who needs extra comfort.” The company refers to their cushioning as “Lusso Cloud,” which rests on a stable, shock-absorbing IP-EVA outsole. 

If you live in an area with long, cold winters or struggle with very cold feet, these Overland sheepskin slippers are the answer. The upper, insole, and collar are all made of Australian Merino sheepskin to envelope your feet in toasty warmth. But they’re also delightfully supportive thanks to the memory foam midsole and shock-absorbing EVA outsole with arch support. Swanson, who tried them, said they were quite warm and supportive, although she warned they would likely be too hot for warmer climates.

“When you first put your foot into this slipper, you instantly go, ‘Oh my.’ The sheepskin is so darn soft, you wish you were wearing this as a blanket,” she said. “They are very comfortable to stand in for long periods of time, mostly due to the extra cushion that has been added.”

If you’re looking for ultimate plush, cozy comfort and cushioning, these Minnetonka Tahoe clogs serve up just that. From the sweater knit and suede upper to the lush pile lining and contoured insole, these slippers are made with comfort in mind. “They are so, so comfortable. In fact, they're my favorite ones of all the slippers I tried,” said Scully, who tested them. “They also get more comfortable the more you wear them as they adjust to your foot.”

Because these slippers conform to your foot, they stay on well without rubbing, Scully found. They also fit true to size, which we appreciate. The treaded hard-bottom sole makes them super-versatile. They’re cute, too, so there's no shame in wearing them while running errands. The insoles are removable, allowing you to replace them with custom orthotics if needed. If you’re looking for a similar style in men’s sizing, check out the Minnetonka Taylor clogs.

These Bombas Sunday Slippers are made of soft, warm, and fluffy sherpa on the inside and out. But the star here is the cushy, supportive memory foam and EVA midsole. It’s like a little memory-foam mattress for each foot. This high level of support, combined with the grippy rubber outsole, makes this a fabulous indoor-outdoor option. Ziegler, who tested them, couldn’t stop raving about them.

“The memory foam molds to your foot,” she said. “These are by far my favorite slipper I've tried. I keep going back to them again and again. They're warm, cushy, and aren't too fluffy. I love them.” We found the memory foam provided enough support for high arches, despite the lack of dedicated built-in arch support. While Ziegler had nothing but good things to say, some reviewers note that these slippers may slip off the back of their feet. They’re also available in men’s sizes.